Meeting a New Friend
Recently I have been spending a lot of time (and practice hours) thinking about the Mook Yan Jong. This type of wooden dummy is commonly used in Wing Chun schools around the world. I had not been planning on buying a dummy. I don’t really have the space for one at the moment. But when my Sifu called me up and told me that he was arranging for a container shipment to be sent from China, and that the new Jong would be ridiculously cheap, I couldn’t say no.
A few weeks later I found myself opening a large box with a honey blond laminated wooden dummy. I was pleasantly surprised to find that my model had been shipped with a stand, so I was left with no excuse but to put the whole thing together, squeeze it into the corner of a room that was already too small, and begin to practice.
I did not have regular access to a dummy for a couple of years, and my form had gotten a bit rusty. I had been practicing the other unarmed forms on a daily basis and was even able to get some chi sao training (“sticky hands,” a type of sensitivity training) with the students that I teach. Still, there had been a definite “wooden dummy shaped hole” in my soul.
It did not take too long to get the basic choreography of the form dialed in. Still, the process may have been slowed as the new Jong did not feel quite “right” at first. That is to say it does not feel like my Sifu’s old dummy, the one that I learned on.
The geometry, weight and materials on my new dummy are all correct, but it is interesting how even small differences can really be felt when you start to spend a lot of time working on them. Minor changes in the diameter of the arms, the profile of the leg, or how easily the Jong slides back and forth on its rails, are things that can be immediately felt.
Probably the biggest adjustment that I am dealing with right now is the mounting system. Most “living” Jongs are suspended on two slats, which act like springs (see above). These thin strips of wood need to be just the right width so that they can support the dummy, but at the same time allow it fall back and then spring forward if it is struck the right way.
Many people who don’t work with dummies erroneously assume that they are static conditioning devices. Nothing could be further from the truth. A good dummy can be uncannily responsive to a martial artist’s movement. The wooden spring on a hanging Wing Chun Jong are generally mounted into brackets that are screwed into studs in the wall to insure that the whole thing is held securely in place.
My model was shipped with a stand-alone frame, which was truly fortunate as I don’t think that my wife would appreciate it if I permanently mounted my “new friend” on the wall of the bedroom. But given its weight and the forces that a dummy is subjected to, getting these freestanding frames to function properly can be kind of tricky.
To be totally honest I have no idea who made my dummy, or how much experience they have. But they ended up building a system that was actually pretty clever. The dummy itself hangs on very thick cross-beams. These have none of the “spring” that one expects to see in the normal sorts of slats that are employed in most wall mount systems. The rest of the frame, which doesn’t appear to be too heavily built, just blots together.
It would be an understatement to say that I was ambivalent about how the entire thing was going to work. I just figured that at some point I would probably have to make another, more substantial, frame. Fortunately this stand has greatly exceeded my expectations.
It actually has all of the stability and spring that one could want in a dummy. Obviously the key to creating the stability is to weight the base of the stand down with rice or sand bags. I think that this is where a lot of people go wrong. They never get the stability that they need to really apply the proper force to a freestanding dummy because they don’t use enough weight. Given my size and technique I found that I needed about 150 lbs of additional weight to create a level of stability that I was comfortable with.
Once the base of the stand was properly weighted I discovered that the vertical upright poles on the left and right side which held the horizontal supports in place were capable of providing all of the “spring” that I really needed to do my dummy form. Part of this “springing” motion actually comes from the wooden poles flexing. The rest is provided by the natural play where the uprights are bolted to the various pieces of the base assembly.
In short, this dummy works because the stand is really rather clever. Rather than simply trying to imitate a typical wall-mounted system (which would have been impossible to copy) it put the “springs” in the vertical parts of stand, not the horizontal. The owner still needs to weight everything down to really make it work. But I was genuinely surprised what a secure stand the manufacturer was able to put together for practically no money at all. I think that this is a great example of the “hacker spirit” that you see in so many places in the martial arts world.
The fit and finish on my new dummy is pretty rough in places, even though it is substantially built. No one would look at this and conclude that it was the work of a “master craftsman.” But given that this is a tool that I plan on punching and kicking for the next 5-10 years, I think that it has everything I need.
All of these positive qualities notwithstanding, it still feels very different from the Jong that my teacher taught me the form on. I can’t count how many dozens (maybe hundreds) of hours I spent on that dummy. It had its own eccentricities. The geometry of its arms was great, but the body was a bit light.
By the numbers my new dummy is probably a better piece of training equipment. Yet it still feels like a stranger. I suppose that it is not all that different from working with a new training partner, someone who seems nice enough but who is basically an unknown quantity. I think that we are going to be friends, but only time can tell.
The Wooden Dummy as the Teacher of Wing Chun Theory
My new Jong has really given me a lot to think about. Besides the immediate questions of engineering that go into making a piece of equipment like this functional, it is also forcing me to study and rethink aspects of the form that had gotten a little fuzzy in the last few years.
First one must learn (or review) the basic sequence of movements taught in every modern lineage of Wing Chun. Yet the actual “arguments” and “questions” advanced by the dummy form go well beyond realm of mere choreography. Of all of the forms in Wing Chun, I believe that the dummy’s is the most interactive and requires the highest level of thoughtful engagement by the student.
Wing Chun’s basic unarmed forms tend to be abstract. This is the easiest to see with Siu Lim Tao (the introductory set), but the same quality is also present in Chum Kiu and Biu Jee. Siu Lim Tao presents the students with a set of movements. Unlike in other Asian martial arts, these are not arranged into a mock battle or a “shadow boxing” routine. There is no enemy to visualize when you are doing the forms. Or if there is an “enemy” he would be incredibly erratic.
Instead these forms read like reference books on the basic structures used by the system. In Siu Lim Tao the new student is introduced to the fighting zones, the basic punch, and then all of the different ways that the arm can move as a variant of that one punch. As Ip Ching has observed, in the introductory form one movement comes after another, but there is no logical dependence of the second on the first. There is no tactical reason to expect that the second movement should always come next.
One way to think about Siu Lim Tao is as an organizational system to help the student think more systematically about the possibilities of human movement and how they might apply to fighting. It is not random. It has its own logic, but it’s the same sort of logic that one would encounter if you were to sit down and read the dictionary.
Siu Lim Tao presents the new student with a collection of basic movements that form the alphabet of Wing Chun. In the next two forms students are shown how to string those letters together into words and sentences. But the project remains somewhat abstract. And as an abstract conversation about the nature of human movement, it is also pretty universal.
All of this changes when a student approaches the dummy. Different chapters of the dummy form display some variety in their logic, but all of them have a tactical progression. In each case there is a very specific reason that one movement follows the next. In some instances the student reacts to an “attack” by the dummy, in others he strings together movements into simple combinations or complex patterns of entry and evasion. Whereas the early unarmed forms were about establishing a language of movement, the dummy asks its practitioner to begin to formulate these into more complex arguments about the nature of fighting.
This has a definite impact on the attitude that one must approach the dummy with. As Ip Ching and Heimberger have argued, this form requires a high degree of mindfulness (see Ip Ching and Ron Heimberger. Mook Yan Jong Sum Fat. 2004 for what remains one of the best discussions of the Wing Chun wooden dummy tradition). Rather than simply stringing the various movements together in a choreographed routine, students must strive to “react” instantly and naturally to the dummy’s actions. Only in this way can you begin to build the correct power and intent into the various sections of the form.
One of the areas where this becomes evident is in the footwork and movement of the dummy set. This form cannot be practiced from a static position. Instead different chapters require students to move into, or away from, the dummy at various angles. One must apply the lessons of Chum Kiu to move from one side of the dummy to the other while still projecting power forward, into its core, rather than just sliding across the arms. Vitally important is to learn how to coordinate the hips and subtle shifts necessary to give the movements their proper alignment, speed and power.
Of course all of these things should also be part of chi sao. Students should be used to starting from “unbridged” positions. They should be comfortable working on entry and kicking. Yet, for a variety of reasons, this often doesn’t happen. A lot of chi sao is somewhat static, focusing only a single range with limited structures. This is often the case when working with students who are still new to the system. The dummy forces the more advanced student to integrate and apply various aspects of the system in new ways.
Of course Wing Chun is not the only southern art to employ a wooden dummy. It is interesting to do a comparative study of various Jong designs and how they reflect/facilitate the training forms that have developed in conjunction with them. Choy Li Fut, which has its own more mechanically complicated dummies, employs a number of broad, sweeping, long distance punches. The length of its Jong’s arms and the strategic placement of ricebags allows for the forceful applications of these special techniques.
I don’t think it would be possible to approach a Wing Chun dummy in quite the same way. One of the points that Ip Ching has argued is that all of the movements in his father’s dummy form are essentially reactive. They all suppose that the dummy has done something, presenting the students with a question that he or she is then forced to respond to. This closely mirrors the classic Chi Sao strategy of establishing a solid structure and being sensitive to mistakes or openings in your opponent’s actions that can be safely exploited.
In short, much of the actual distinctive physical culture of Wing Chun, from specific combinations and defensive techniques, to broader questions of fundamental strategy, are encapsulated and taught through the dummy form. Again, none of this material should be totally new to the student. Each of these elements will have likely been introduced somewhere else. And students will spend a lot of time working the specific “lessons” or “applications” of this form. But the dummy is unique in its ability to bring all of these fundamental insights together in one place, while challenging students to build a more complete understanding of the various aspects of their art.
The Mook Yan Jong allows students to study, practice and contemplate aspects of the Wing Chun system in a way that is unique. It disciplines and amplifies the style’s approach to combat. In some senses, the dummy form is where we move beyond the more universal elements boxing and begin to contemplate Wing Chun’s specific answers to the question of interpersonal violence.
“Embodiment” has become an important topic in the academic study of the martial arts over the last ten years or so. These fighting systems do seem to have a remarkable capacity to generate and convey transformative understandings of the self from teacher to student. Ethnographers have noted that much of this instruction happens through non-verbal channels of physical culture, as individual postures, energies and motions are conveyed from one generation to the next.
Of course it is pretty much impossible to learn a meaningful version of the dummy form without a teacher. Still, I have always been struck by how large a percentage of Wing Chun’s theory is actually taught and reinforced by this one unique training tool. For advanced Wing Chun students it opens an avenue for solo exploration and experimentation that is somewhat unique for a “sensitivity” based art. Indeed, the image of the lone Wing Chun master, working with his dummy for hours on end, has recently come to dominate the popular imagination.
Nor is this image wholly inaccurate. Once one begins to “respond naturally” to the questions posed by the dummy, it is pretty easy to lose an hour on free flowing experimentation and improvisation.
The Dummy as a Shared Symbol in the Southern Chinese Martial Arts
One does not need to be an experienced Wing Chun student to be fascinated by wooden dummies, or to draw a certain sort of meaning out of them. Indeed, images of deadly, seemingly diabolical, wooden training devices are a central aspect of the Shaolin mythos. The late Qing wuxia novel “Everlasting” (discussed at some length by Hamm) told of a special hall in the southern Shaolin Temple. In an attempt to insure discipline, and the strength of his order’s reputation, the Abbot decreed that no student could leave the school without passing each of the tests posed by these wooden dummies.
The image of the Hall of Wooden Dummy Men proved to be explosively popular. It was adopted as gospel by later Shaolin storytellers. It made appearances in Hong Kong actions films and on 1970s American television programs. Echoes of this perilous testing device can even be seen in the elaborate training machinery (complete with “wooden crock-bandits”) of the current Kung Fu Panda cartoons.
Given this strong mythic tradition stretching back to at least the 19th century, it is no surprise that the various Kung Fu and opera schools of Southern China (the vast majority of which claim to be descended from the Shaolin Temple) would adopt some variant of the wooden training dummy. Indeed, as useful as they are, the value of the Jong has never been entirely defined only by its practical functions. The very existence of such a device in a school bore a solid physical testimony to the lineage’s “Shaolin heritage.” To master the construction and use of the dummy was to place oneself within the sacred time of the Shaolin archetype.
Notice that one does not need to make a choice between wooden dummies being valued in the southern arts for their practical importance or their mythic associations. In the case of this powerful symbol the two went together. The hours spent practicing the dummy were more than just training, they were (and remain) an almost ritualized activity. The myth of Shaolin gave this action social meaning and relevance. This allowed the student to transform his or her understanding of self at the same time that the discipline of the dummy refined their approach to Kung Fu.
Today the Mook Yan Jong is once again emerging as a master symbol of the southern Chinese martial arts. It is starting to appear in new and strange places, far from the styles that originally taught it. Bruce Lee and his association with Wing Chun helped to spread knowledge about Chinese wooden dummies in the 1970s and 1980s. More recently big budget films focusing on his teacher, Ip Man, have glamorized this once esoteric training tool, making it a virtual necessity in any well-appointed school.
It is interesting to watch to various the Ip Man films and note when dummies appear. Wilson Ip used the Jong as a key visual symbol in his bio-pic. In fact, the movie’s opening shot featured Donnie Yen (as Ip Man) hard at work on his dummy, planted in middle of a well-appointed Chinese living room. This one sequence did a lot of work for the director, establishing for the audience Ip Man’s essential nature as a solitary Kung Fu master. Here was someone lost deep in thought, but he kept those thoughts to himself.
One might next want to compare these scenes to the more realistic portrayal of the role of wooden dummies in Herman Lau’s film, “Ip Man the Final Fight.” This project was the most historically faithful of all of the Ip Man movies. For instance, Wing Chun aficionados will appreciate the sudden appearance of a hanging (or “Living”) Jong once Ip Man moves into a small apartment. Of course this style of dummy, now the most commonly seen, was invented by the historic Ip Man as a solution to the constraints of training in small apartments in Hong Kong’s crowded cityscape.
Collectively these films have done much to promote Wing Chun among a new generation of martial arts students. Donnie Yen’s performance seems to have had the greatest impact on most of the new pupils that I have talked to. And all of them, without exception, have been captivated by the image of him working on the dummy. It seems that for another generation of Wing Chun students the physical existence of the dummy has become an assurance of the authenticity of their new schools practice.
Still, this sense of fascination goes well beyond new Wing Chun students. Since the release of the first Ip Man film wooden dummies have started to appear in a wide range of schools that have no connection to Wing Chun or the southern fighting arts more generally. This has even led to a transformation in the commercial market for dummies.
It used to be much more difficult to get a decent dummy. Few individuals outside of the southern Kung Fu schools were all that interested in the various types of Jongs. And due to the constraints of space and cost most students were simply content to use their teacher’s dummies for years at a time (much as I did). As a result there were not all that many commercial makers of these items. Given the difficulty in manufacturing and shipping a decent dummy, it didn’t seem like the sort of thing that anyone would get rich selling.
The situation today is somewhat different. A number of small companies in North America and Europe are making very nice dummies, as are a handful of manufactures in Asia. Recently a large number of firms in China have jumped on the bandwagon and have begun to mass produce dummies. Both the quality and price of these models can vary tremendously, so one must do their due diligence. Yet it is clear that there is now a market for dummies beyond the traditional Wing Chun buyers.
I occasionally wonder about how these other Jongs are likely to be used (or if they will be used at all). It is not advisable to simply walk up to wooden dummy and start punching it like it’s a heavy bag. Using the Jong safely and effectively requires the adoption of certain angles and distances that could be very different from whatever style these buyers might be most familiar with. Of course there are a number of DVD’s and Youtube videos offering to teach the dummy form, though I am not sure how helpful they would be to someone from a structurally incompatible art.
In the end I suspect that many of these dummies are being bought more for their symbolic than practical value. While watching cartoons with a nephew I recently saw that the animators had included a wooden dummy in a ninja training hall on the popular show “Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.” I was forced to wonder what a bunch of traditional Japanese assassins were planning on doing with a Wing Chun Jong, but it seemed pretty natural to my nephew. The myth of the Hall of the Wooden Dummy Men, translated through the lens of Ip Man’s struggle against imperialism and economic marginalization, is once again spreading the influence of the Southern Shaolin arts.
Conclusion: Listening to the Mook Yan Jong as an Ethnographic Artifact
Ethnographic artifacts play an important role in certain sorts of cultural and anthropological studies. Students of the martial arts seem to understand this intuitively. The weapons, training tools, publications and fine arts created by hand combat students all tell us something about the world that they lived in. Wooden dummies are a particularly rich source of insight for those interested in the history and evolving social identity of the southern Chinese martial arts. While I have briefly discussed the historic evolution of Jongs elsewhere, I think that at some point it might be fun to do a history of Wing Chun told from the perspective of the physical and symbolic evolution of the wooden dummies that it has come to be so closely associated with.
As artifacts dummies are uniquely illuminating. To a practitioner they reveal a wealth of encapsulated information about the basic nature, and assumptions, behind an art.
As a student of martial studies they tell me exactly where I am located in the evolution of the Wing Chun (and southern Chinese martial arts community more generally). Is it a “buried” dummy or a “living” one? Is it laminated, solid or PVC? Was it made in Hong Kong, China or North America? Each of these small differences tells me something important about how Wing Chun has traveled the currents of globalization, and where I am actually situated on this foggy sea.
The anthropologist Victor Turner once observed that all artifacts seem to have two properties, one practical and the other symbolic. Something as utilitarian as a digging stick might be sharpened on one end, and adorned with a feather on the other. Nowhere is this tendency more pronounced than in the realms of traditional Chinese weapons and military training. The humble woven rattan shield was often pained with auspicious designs and red tassels were tied to the ringed hilts of peasant swords.
This same basic tendency is evident in the history and spread of the wooden dummy. For so many modern students and consumers, mastery, or even simply the purchase, of a dummy is a way of uniting themselves with either a mythic past or a lineage of revered ancestors. On a purely symbolic level it can do the former whereas actual study of its techniques might help to accomplish the latter. Yet as these tools “unite” us with the past, they also reveal the many subtle (and sometimes profound) disjoints that mark the modern martial arts as being distinct and separate.
By studing any group of artifacts we can learn something about the society that created and used them. Yet as the Mook Yan Jong reminds us, within martial studies the key to doing this effectively is to remember that these things will often carry more than one set of meanings. On the one hand they may help to convey the shared physical culture of a specific fighting art. In that sense they would seem to be tightly tied to the question of “embodiment.”
Yet no symbol or bodily experience is totally self-interpreting. As such these artifacts are likely to have a symbolic or socially constructed meaning that goes well beyond their technical use. It may even stretch beyond the small group of practitioners who specialize in the exploitation of a given object. This socially defined meaning might draw off of a wide variety of other practices, stories or media. The challenge for students of martial studies when looking at the use or evolution of something like Wing Chun’s wooden dummy is to find a way to synthesize both their practical and social meaning. In order to learn something new about the groups that use these tools we need to be able to understand them from both of these perspectives.
If you enjoyed this you might also want to read: The Dadao and the Militarization of the Chinese Martial Arts.
March 24, 2014 at 12:12 pm
I couldn’t help thinking of the journey to hell and back. It was a common theme in plays, and local versions of the epics often had a journey to hell scene worked in. Of course these were usually mimed, but I believe there was a temple carnival version, sort of like a house of mirrors or a makeshift haunted house in the west. In any event this type of play was even more common in shadow plays because they could show all the torture devices. The language of “buried vs. live” does suggest the supernatural. Could this device be training for the journey to hell?